LCLWeb

Best Hotels in Islamorada: Where to Stay for an Unforgettable Vacation

Daniel Parkinson
2 months ago

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of hotels in Islamorada, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
Cheeca Lodge & Spa

8.6 / 10

(1126 Reviews)

 From 639$
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

8.0 / 10

(1264 Reviews)

 From 180$
The Moorings Village

9.3 / 10

(11 Reviews)

 From 459$
Pelican Cove Resort & Marina

8.0 / 10

(1005 Reviews)

 From 199$
Amara Cay Resort

8.2 / 10

(703 Reviews)

 From 266$

Nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, Islamorada is not just a destination, but a tropical paradise that captivates the soul of every traveler. It's where the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico merge, creating a haven for fishing, diving, and watersports. For those looking to immerse in this serene escape, choosing the right hotel in Islamorada is crucial, as it becomes your home base for exploring the enchanting coral reefs, rich marine life, and breathtaking sunsets that define this area.

The hotels in Islamorada are more than just places to stay; they're gateways to experiences that stay with you long after you've left. From luxurious oceanfront resorts with private beaches to cozy, boutique hotels that tell a story, the accommodations here cater to diverse tastes and budgets. Each hotel offers unique amenities tailored to enhance your island adventure, be it through on-site water sport rentals, eco-tours, or simply a hammock under the palms, underscoring the essence of a true Florida Keys experience.

Planning your stay in Islamorada doesn't have to be overwhelming. Insightful recommendations on the top hotels will not only ease the process but ensure you make the most of your visit. Whether you're here for the world-class tarpon fishing, the vibrant local art scene, or the tranquil beauty of the Keys, finding the perfect hotel in Islamorada will elevate your trip from a simple getaway to an unforgettable journey into paradise.

Table of contents

The Caribbean Resort Cheeca Lodge & Spa Luxury Hotels in Islamorada Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina The Moorings Village Boutique Hotels in Islamorada Pelican Cove Resort & Marina Amara Cay Resort Family-Friendly Hotels in Islamorada Islander Resort Casa Morada Hotel

View all photos

The Caribbean Resort

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 117 Carroll St

From 450$

The Caribbean Resort at Sea Isle stands as a testament to Islamorada's rich history and natural beauty, offering guests a boutique experience that is deeply rooted in the local culture. This resort, hidden away on a private estate, features unique villas and cottages that provide a sense of exclusivity and privacy. Each accommodation is meticulously decorated to reflect the island's maritime heritage, with stunning views of the lush gardens or the azure waters. The Caribbean Resort offers activities such as boat rentals, fishing expeditions, and guided eco-tours, allowing guests to explore the marvels of Islamorada first-hand. With its intimate setting and dedication to capturing the essence of the Florida Keys, this resort stands out among hotels in Islamorada for those seeking a blend of history, culture, and modern luxury.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Luxury Hotels in Islamorada

For those seeking a lavish getaway in Islamorada, the luxury hotels dotting this picturesque key offer more than just a place to stay; they promise a transformative experience. Blending opulence with the natural beauty of the Florida Keys, these establishments provide exquisite accommodations, unparalleled service, and amenities that cater to your every desire. From private beaches and gourmet dining to personalized excursions, the luxury hotels in Islamorada are sanctuaries of relaxation and indulgence. These havens are designed for discerning travelers who seek the pinnacle of comfort and elegance, making your island retreat unforgettable. Here, every detail is meticulously crafted to ensure an experience as unique as Islamorada itself.

View all photos

8.6
Excellent
1126 Reviews

Cheeca Lodge & Spa

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 81801 Overseas Highway, Mile Marker 82

From 639$

Cheeca Lodge & Spa stands as a beacon of luxury in Islamorada, offering guests an escape into elegance and serenity. Within its sprawling estate, visitors find a blend of refined comfort and tropical allure, with spacious rooms and suites that offer breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean. This hotel is a sanctuary where the ocean's edge meets impeccable service, featuring a private beach, a 9-hole golf course, and a world-class spa. Dining at Cheeca is an epicurean delight, with several restaurants serving fresh local seafood and international cuisine. For adventurers, the resort offers on-site fishing charters, water sports, and eco-tours, ensuring every moment is infused with the essence of the Keys. Cheeca Lodge & Spa is a testament to the luxury that defines hotels in Islamorada, making it an unmatched choice for those seeking refinement and relaxation.
Check Availability
Add to compare

View all photos

8
Very good
1264 Reviews

Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 84001 Overseas Highway

From 180$

The Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina offers a quintessential Islamorada experience for families looking to soak up the sun, sea, and spirited adventure of the Florida Keys. The resort's beachfront location provides the perfect playground for water sports enthusiasts of all ages, with offerings such as snorkeling, paddleboarding, and kayaking. Families can choose from a variety of room types, including spacious suites that accommodate larger groups comfortably. The resort also hosts a range of activities designed to entertain children and adults alike, making every day a new discovery. With its iconic Tiki bar, on-site marina, and pet-friendly policy, Postcard Inn is a hub of relaxation and adventure for families visiting Islamorada.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Boutique Hotels in Islamorada

Islamorada is not only known for its sprawling luxury resorts but also for its charming boutique hotels that offer a unique and personalized lodging experience. These establishments are distinguished by their distinctive style, exceptional service, and intimate scale, providing a cozy contrast to the larger resorts. Boutique hotels in Islamorada are perfect for travelers seeking a more personalized touch to their stay, with each property telling its own story through design, amenities, and localized experiences. From historical properties that have been thoughtfully restored to contemporary retreats that celebrate the island's natural beauty, these hotels provide a memorable and immersive way to experience Islamorada. Here, you'll find a selection of hotels where attention to detail and a passion for hospitality create unforgettable stays.

View all photos

9.3
Excellent
11 Reviews

The Moorings Village

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 123 Beach Rd

From 459$

Nestled on a lush, 18-acre property, The Moorings Village provides an intimate setting for those looking to indulge in the luxury side of Keys' laid-back living. This idyllic resort features private, beautifully designed cottages, each offering unique views of the stunning tropical gardens or the crystal-clear ocean. The Moorings Village boasts a 1,100-foot private beach, often considered one of the most beautiful in Islamorada, perfect for sunbathing, swimming, or simply contemplating the horizon. Guests can take advantage of the on-site spa services, yoga classes, and exclusive access to water sports equipment. The historic property not only offers privacy and luxury but also stands as a testament to the island's charm and elegance, making it an unparalleled choice among hotels in Islamorada for those seeking tranquility and exclusivity.
Check Availability
Add to compare

View all photos

8
Very good
1005 Reviews

Pelican Cove Resort & Marina

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 84457 Overseas Highway

From 199$

For families seeking a blend of adventure and relaxation, Pelican Cove Resort & Marina presents an ideal setting. Situated directly on the Atlantic Ocean, the resort offers immediate access to pristine beaches and a world of water-based activities. Accommodations are designed with families in mind, providing comfort and convenience alongside stunning ocean views. The resort's saltwater lagoon, pool, and cabana cafe create a tranquil environment for relaxation, while fishing charters, eco-tours, and water sport rentals are readily available for those looking to explore the natural beauty of Islamorada. Pelican Cove's dedication to creating a family-friendly atmosphere, complete with educational programs about the local marine life, ensures a memorable experience for guests of all ages.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Family-Friendly Hotels in Islamorada

Islamorada is a paradise for family vacations, offering an array of experiences that can be enjoyed by visitors of all ages. The family-friendly hotels in Islamorada are designed to cater to the needs of both adults and children, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay for everyone. These hotels not only provide spacious accommodations and child-friendly amenities but also feature various on-site activities and programs specifically geared toward younger guests. From pools with shallow areas to kids' clubs offering educational and fun activities related to the local ecosystem, these family-oriented establishments make it easy to create lasting memories. Here, families can rest easy knowing their accommodation choice enhances their Islamorada adventure.

View all photos

8.2
Very good
703 Reviews

Amara Cay Resort

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 80001 Overseas Highway

From 266$

Amara Cay Resort emphasizes sustainability without sacrificing style or comfort, making it an attractive choice for environmentally conscious travelers. The resort employs green practices such as energy-efficient lighting, water conservation programs, and the use of eco-friendly cleaning products. Nestled along the ocean, Amara Cay integrates the natural beauty of Islamorada into its design and atmosphere, offering guests an immersive experience that is both luxurious and mindful of environmental impact. The resort's on-site restaurant specializes in dishes made from fresh, local ingredients, supporting the local economy and reducing the carbon footprint. Amara Cay's commitment to eco-friendly hospitality, combined with its stunning location and sophisticated amenities, exemplifies the balance between luxury and sustainability.
Check Availability
Add to compare

View all photos

8.5
Very good
1499 Reviews

Islander Resort

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 82100 Overseas Highway

From 204$

Islander Resort is a treasure trove of family fun, offering spacious oceanfront accommodations and a host of amenities that cater to the young and the young at heart. With two saltwater pools, a splash pad, and a private beach spread across its lush, tropical grounds, there's no shortage of water activities to enjoy. The resort also features on-site dining with kid-friendly menu options, making meal times easy and enjoyable for the whole family. For those looking to venture beyond the resort, Islander's convenient location makes exploring Islamorada's attractions a breeze. The resort's commitment to family-friendly experiences, coupled with its comprehensive amenities, makes it a standout choice for families visiting the enchanting keys of Islamorada.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Eco-Friendly Hotels in Islamorada

In an era where sustainability is more important than ever, Islamorada has seen a rise in eco-friendly hotels committed to preserving the natural beauty of the Florida Keys while providing exceptional guest experiences. These eco-conscious accommodations employ a variety of green practices, from solar energy and water conservation measures to offering organic, locally sourced food options. Guests can enjoy the tranquil beauty of Islamorada with a minimal environmental footprint, staying in hotels that emphasize ecological responsibility alongside comfort and luxury. These establishments not only cater to eco-savvy travelers but also contribute to the broader efforts of conserving the unique ecosystems of the Keys. Explore these eco-friendly hotels in Islamorada and take a step towards a more sustainable vacation experience.

View all photos

9
Excellent
78 Reviews

Casa Morada Hotel

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 136 Madeira Road

From 320$

Casa Morada seamlessly blends luxury with the natural beauty of the Florida Keys, offering a boutique hotel experience that is both intimate and refined. This waterfront property, exclusively for adults, ensures a peaceful retreat with 16 individually decorated suites, each reflecting the serene beauty of its surroundings. Guests can enjoy a private island feel with access to a secluded pool, a seafront gazebo, and complimentary water sports like kayaking and snorkeling. Casa Morada's approach to luxury is understated yet evident in the meticulous attention to detail and personalized service. The hotel organizes sunset cruises and eco-tours, making it a perfect spot for couples and solo travelers looking for a serene, luxurious escape. Its unparalleled location and offerings make Casa Morada a jewel among hotels in Islamorada, epitomizing the tranquil luxury that the Keys are celebrated for.
Check Availability
Add to compare

For those visitors whose dream vacation includes waking up to the sound of waves and being just steps away from the ocean, researching Islamorada hotels on the beach becomes an essential part of trip planning. These oceanfront stays provide an exceptional experience, blending comfort with the natural beauty that Islamorada is renowned for. Imagine starting your day with a coffee on a private balcony facing the vast ocean or winding down with a sunset that paints the sky in shades of orange and pink. Options range from lavish resorts to intimate inns, each with its own character, ensuring every traveler finds a beachfront haven that feels like it was made just for them.

To delve deeper into what the island has to offer, visitors should consider exploring the variety of hotels in Islamorada Florida, which span from the heart of downtown to the more secluded areas, offering a retreat for every preference. These accommodations are not just a place to sleep; they are integral parts of the Islamorada experience. With amenities such as guided fishing expeditions, spa services, and on-site dining featuring fresh, local seafood, these hotels ensure that every aspect of your Florida Keys adventure is memorable. Each hotel has its unique way of showcasing the island's charm, from artful decor that reflects the vibrant marine life to eco-friendly practices that harmonize with the natural surroundings.

Location