Top Shipshewana Hotels for an Authentic Experience

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Daniel Parkinson

Updated: 05 January 2024 · 4 min

Nestled in the very heart of Indiana's Amish country, Shipshewana is not just a destination; it's an experience wrapped in the warmth and charm of the Midwest. This quaint town, known for its rich cultural history and serene landscapes, invites visitors to step back in time while enjoying modern comforts. Among these comforts are the Shipshewana hotels, which serve as cozy retreats for travelers seeking both adventure and tranquility in this unique corner of the United States.

Shipshewana's accommodations are as diverse as the experiences it offers, ranging from charming bed and breakfasts to full-service hotels that cater to every whim. Each hotel in Shipshewana is more than just a place to stay; it's a gateway to exploring the local Amish community, bustling flea markets, and breathtaking countryside. Recommendations often highlight the personalized service and local hospitality that these hotels offer, ensuring a stay that's both memorable and authentic.

Moreover, insights into Shipshewana's hotel scene reveal a commitment to preserving the town's heritage while offering modern amenities. Many hotels feature handcrafted furniture and décor that reflect the local Amish craftsmanship, allowing guests to immerse themselves fully in the cultural experience. With an array of options tailored to different tastes and budgets, Shipshewana hotels stand ready to welcome visitors with open arms, promising comfort, connection, and a touch of magic that can only be found in this enchanting part of the United States.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 8

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Shipshewana Guest House With Fire Pit!
2. Cozy Amish Country Cabin On Shipshewana Lake!
3. Der Ruhe Blatz Motel
4. Blue Gate Garden Inn
5. Blue Birds Perch Stunning Home On Private Hilltop
6. Farmstead Inn And Conference Center
7. Super 8 By Wyndham Shipshewana Hotel
8. Van Buren Hotel

Traditional Amish-Inspired Shipshewana Hotels

Check Availability

Shipshewana
Sep 18, 2025 - Sep 19, 2025

Shipshewana Guest House With Fire Pit!

9.7

Good

(18 Reviews)

+ 19 photos
The Shipshewana Guest House With Fire Pit! offers an intimate and cozy getaway, emphasizing outdoor living with its inviting fire pit area, perfect for evenings under the stars. This charming guesthouse goes beyond traditional hotel amenities by providing a home-like environment, complete with a fully equipped kitchen, comfortable living spaces, and a setting that encourages relaxation and connection with nature. The property's location allows guests to easily explore Shipshewana's attractions while offering a private retreat to unwind. Its blend of convenience and charm, along with the unique outdoor fire pit feature, makes it an appealing choice for families and small groups seeking a personalized stay in Shipshewana.
Address: 7646 W 075 N
Rating: Good 9.7 (18 Reviews)
Price: From 142$

Cozy Amish Country Cabin On Shipshewana Lake!

9.1

Good

(9 Reviews)

+ 18 photos
For those dreaming of a tranquil lakeside escape, the Cozy Amish Country Cabin On Shipshewana Lake! is a hidden gem that promises serenity and scenic views. This cabin offers a rustic yet comfortable setting, with interiors that reflect the natural beauty of its surroundings. Guests can enjoy access to Shipshewana Lake, making this an ideal spot for fishing, kayaking, or simply soaking in the peaceful ambiance. The cabin's charm lies in its balance of seclusion and accessibility, providing a private haven that remains close to the heart of Shipshewana. This unique accommodation is perfect for travelers seeking a deeper connection with nature without sacrificing the convenience of proximity to the town's attractions and amenities.
Address: Shipshewana, IN, 46565
Rating: Good 9.1 (9 Reviews)
Price: From 287$

Experience Shipshewana: Hotels with Modern Comforts

While Shipshewana is renowned for its Amish heritage, visitors do not have to compromise on modern comforts. The hotels in this section represent the best of both worlds, blending contemporary amenities with the charm and hospitality Shipshewana is known for. These accommodations are perfect for travelers who appreciate the local culture but also enjoy the conveniences modern life offers. From indoor pools to state-of-the-art fitness centers, these hotels ensure a comfortable and convenient stay without straying far from the essence of Shipshewana. Whether it's a family vacation, a romantic getaway, or a business trip, these hotels cater to all needs, making every visit a memorable one.

Der Ruhe Blatz Motel

8.2

Good

(1515 Reviews)

+ 53 photos
Nestled in the lively heart of Shipshewana, the Der Ruhe Blatz Motel embodies the tranquility its name suggests. This motel offers a window into Amish craftsmanship, with beautifully hand-carved furnishings and a serene, comfortable atmosphere that echoes the simple life. Guests can enjoy modern amenities set against a backdrop of quiet rural charm, creating a perfect balance between convenience and authenticity. The motel’s exterior, with its traditional wooden architecture, invites guests into a world where time slows down. A stay at Der Ruhe Blatz Motel isn't just about comfort; it's an opportunity to immerse in Shipshewana's cultural heritage, making it a favorite among travelers seeking an authentic Amish experience. Located conveniently close to local attractions, it serves as an ideal base for exploring the area's rich culture and history.
Address: 1195 S. Van Buren Street
Rating: Good 8.2 (1515 Reviews)
Rooms: 27
Price: From 64$

Blue Gate Garden Inn

9.1

Good

(2719 Reviews)

+ 87 photos
The Blue Gate Garden Inn stands as a beacon of Shipshewana's traditional values and warmth. From the moment guests step into the lobby, they're welcomed with handcrafted furniture and a cozy fireplace, setting the stage for a truly Amish-inspired stay. The hotel offers a range of accommodations, from standard rooms to luxurious suites, each adorned with Amish-made quilts and locally crafted décor. A complimentary hot breakfast, featuring homemade waffles and Amish peanut butter spread, starts the day off right. The Blue Gate Garden Inn also hosts evening activities, including marshmallow roasts and carriage rides, offering guests a taste of Amish leisure. It's this blend of authentic Amish hospitality and modern comfort that makes the Blue Gate Garden Inn a cornerstone among Shipshewana hotels.
Address: 800 South Van Buren Street
Rating: Good 9.1 (2719 Reviews)
Rooms: 132
Price: From 90$

Unique Stays in Shipshewana: Hotels with a Twist

Shipshewana is not only about traditional Amish culture or modern conveniences; it also offers unique accommodations that provide an unforgettable experience. This section dives into hotels that stand out for their distinctive characteristics, from stunning architectural designs to niche thematic elements that promise guests more than just a place to sleep. These hotels are perfect for travelers looking to add an extra layer of excitement and novelty to their Shipshewana visit, combining comfort with creativity in exciting ways.

Blue Birds Perch Stunning Home On Private Hilltop

10.0

Good

(2 Reviews)

+ 31 photos
The Blue Birds Perch Stunning Home On Private Hilltop stands as a testament to luxury and privacy, offering breathtaking views from its vantage point atop a secluded hill. This exquisite property combines elegance with a sense of escape, featuring spacious and beautifully decorated rooms that cater to both relaxation and entertainment. The outdoor area, with its panoramic views, adds an unparalleled dimension to the guest experience. Amenities such as a modern kitchen, luxurious bathrooms, and large living spaces make it an ideal choice for those seeking a high-end retreat in Shipshewana. For travelers who desire an upscale stay with a touch of exclusivity, Blue Birds Perch provides an extraordinary setting that is both memorable and majestic.
Address: 4000 In-5
Rating: Good 10.0 (2 Reviews)
Price: From 333$

Farmstead Inn And Conference Center

9.1

Good

(1126 Reviews)

+ 76 photos
Farmstead Inn And Conference Center perfectly captures the essence of Shipshewana's Amish Country charm. This hotel, with its barn-like structure and quilt-patterned exterior, pays homage to the region's agricultural roots and quilting heritage. Inside, guests will find spacious rooms equipped with modern amenities, alongside furniture and decorations crafted by local artisans. The hotel's indoor pool, basketball court, and arcade games offer a modern twist on relaxation, while the conference center facilities cater to both leisure and business travelers. The complimentary breakfast and proximity to Shipshewana's flea market add convenience to the authentic experience. At the Farmstead Inn, every detail, from the architecture to the friendly service, reflects the spirit of the surrounding Amish community.
Address: 370 S Van Buren St
Rating: Good 9.1 (1126 Reviews)
Rooms: 152
Price: From 92$

Shipshewana's Gateway: Comfortable and Convenient Hotels

Lastly, for visitors who prioritize convenience and comfort above all, Shipshewana offers hotels that serve as the perfect base for exploring the town. These accommodations are chosen for their strategic locations, welcoming atmospheres, and commitment to providing a hassle-free stay. Ideal for those who plan to spend their days discovering Shipshewana's treasures, these hotels ensure a comfortable return at day's end, offering all the necessary amenities to recharge and rejuvenate.

Super 8 By Wyndham Shipshewana Hotel

7.8

Good

(627 Reviews)

+ 27 photos
Super 8 By Wyndham Shipshewana marries the efficiency and reliability of the Wyndham brand with the distinctive charm of Shipshewana. Guests can expect clean, comfortable rooms equipped with all the necessities for a restful stay, including high-speed internet and a complimentary breakfast. The hotel is strategically located near Shipshewana's main attractions, offering convenience for shoppers, culture seekers, and business travelers alike. Super 8's commitment to excellence is evident in every aspect of the guest experience, from the friendly, knowledgeable staff to the thoughtful amenities. This hotel proves that a visit to Shipshewana does not mean leaving behind the comforts and conveniences of modern travel. For those seeking a seamless blend of the local and the contemporary, Super 8 by Wyndham Shipshewana stands ready to welcome you.
Address: 740 South Vanburen Street
Rating: Good 7.8 (627 Reviews)
Rooms: 54
Price: From 73$

Van Buren Hotel

7.9

Good

(869 Reviews)

+ 75 photos
At the heart of Shipshewana lies the Van Buren Hotel, a testament to modern convenience blended with local charm. This hotel offers a serene escape with rooms that provide the utmost comfort, designed to soothe the soul after a day of exploring. The Van Buren is more than just a place to rest; it's a place where guests can enjoy a heated indoor pool, a fitness center, and a daily hot breakfast, ensuring a relaxing and rejuvenating stay. The hotel's friendly staff are well-versed in local lore and eager to share recommendations for exploring Shipshewana's attractions. The Van Buren Hotel excels in offering a friendly, comfortable environment that serves as a home away from home for every guest. It stands out as a beacon of modernity in Shipshewana, making it a prime choice for discerning travelers.
Address: 1175 Van Buren Street
Rating: Good 7.9 (869 Reviews)
Rooms: 84
Price: From 76$

For those eager to delve into the heart of Shipshewana without leaving their furry friends behind, the town's commitment to hospitality extends to pets as well. A selection of pet friendly hotels in shipshewana indiana ensures that every member of your family feels welcome and comfortable. From accommodations with spacious rooms and outdoor areas for your pets to frolic, to services tailored specifically for your four-legged companions, Shipshewana makes it easy to explore its quaint charm and rural beauty alongside your faithful friend. This level of inclusivity and attention to detail highlights the town’s dedication to a memorable and hassle-free stay for all its visitors.

In your search for the perfect stay in Shipshewana, leveraging the latest reviews and insights can greatly enhance your travel planning. Whether you're drawn to the allure of a boutique hotel featuring local Amish craftsmanship or prefer the familiar amenities of a chain hotel, finding the right accommodation can be a breeze with a comprehensive guide to hotels in shipshewana. Such resources not only list available options but also provide valuable information on each hotel's unique offerings, proximity to local attractions, and policies, including pet friendliness. With this information at your fingertips, personalizing your Shipshewana experience to match your interests and needs has never been easier, ensuring a stay that’s as rewarding as it is relaxing.